On my last day in New York I went to Crumbs Bake Shop across from Bryant Park, as I was in a rush to eat it, get back to my hostel and head to the airport I didn’t make a lot of notes on this cupcake.  The cupcake I had was the Bryant Cake cupcake, I know, I’m lame, but I thought there was no better place to eat a Bryant Park cupcake than in Bryant Park.  This cupcake has chocolate cake with chocolate mousse inside, topped with cream cheese icing, chocolate cake crumbs and white chocolate curls – an absolutely divine cupcake.

Flavour: Bryant Park
Cake: 4/5
Icing: 5/5
Presentation: 4/5
Location: 5/5
Flavour Selection: 5/5
Total: 23/25

This was a very good cupcake, though I did find it to be too big.  The cost of a cupcake is $4.50 here, and definitely worth it.  I love cupcakes, but part of the appeal is the individual size of them.  I felt that this would be a cupcake much better shared, which I find difficult to do with a cupcake, especially this one, as it was slightly flaky and hard to hold together – something I typically find with filled cupcakes.  On a nice day, I would definitely recommend sitting in Bryant Park with a Crumbs cupcake as it was a very nice area.  I did a little damage at the Original Penguin store.  All in all I would recommend checking out Crumbs, just make sure you go with an empty stomach as their supersized cupcakes are difficult to finish alone.

This post is a long time coming, I went to For the Love of Cake back in March, but never got around to posting my review.  I first heard about For the Love of Cake because of their Mancakes - you read right – a cupcake made for the men in your life.  These decadent cakes use “man-worthy” ingredients; the flavours range from Maple Bacon to Guinness Chocolate. The other specialty at For the Love of Cake, is the 4-dimensional cupcake, made up of cake, icing, garnish and filing.

On my trip to For the Love of Cake, I made it not too long before closing, meaning I was faced with end of day selection.  The only two flavours offered up were Japanese Ginger and Maple Bacon – being a vegetarian I obviously chose the former.  According to their website the Japanese Ginger is “A tangy ginger cupcake filled with a plum sake reduction and topped with cream cheese frosting and a plum slice covered in a sake glaze.” Needless to say I was intrigued by the complex list of ingredients.

Icing: 5/5
Cake: 5/5
Presentation: 5/5
Location: 2.5/5
Selection: 5/5
Total: 22.5/25

While there were only two flavours available when I went into the store, at the beginning of each day, the bakery tweets (@4theloveofcake) the selection for the day.  At the beginning of the day there are around nine flavours available, so if you want to have full pick, go early in the day!

As I tried the cupcake a while ago, and do not remember the specifics, I can’t go into detail about it.  I would however, recommend going to For the Love of Cake to try their cupcakes for yourself.  The flavours are complex, while there was minimal icing, with the filling I did not desire more.

Currently, Liberty Village seems quite the trek for a cupcake, as the area is not fully developed.  I think as the area grows, it will become a much more desirable area to check out.  Right now, there is a cute boutique located next to the shop, which I would recommend to any fashionista.

Last Thursday after work I ventured over to Dessert Lady (12 Cumberland St.), which is just off of Yonge St. This location really can’t be beat, as it’s in Yorkville, and really close to both the Bay and Yonge-Bloor subway stations. The Dessert Lady specializes in wedding cakes, truffles, cookies and homemade ice cream. Four flavours of cupcakes on their site – Red Velvet, Amaretto, Chocolate and Vanilla. When I went into the store they only had Red Velvet cupcakes, which they have sitting out without icing; upon order they pipe cream cheese icing onto the cake.

Presentation: 3/5
Icing: 4/5
Cake: 3/5
Selection: 1/5
Location: 5/5
Total: 16/25

Despite the high cost of the Dessert Lady’s cupcake, it was exactly the type of cupcake you could make at home. While I know cupcakes in generally range from $2.50-$3, this cupcake fell on the high end of the price spectrum, though the quality of the cupcake did not justify the price. The Dessert Lady has a prime location, and with the higher overall price range of things in Yorkville, it’s understandable that they would have a higher price tag on their cupcake, but honestly, in the future I would buy a cupcake from Starbucks over this one.

For starters, the cake was really dry. I’m a huge fan of red velvet cake, but I was disappointed with the cake portion. The icing was fine, though I felt they should have topped it up much higher to compensate for the dryness of the cake. The icing was a light, cream cheese icing that wasn’t anything special, but was the best part of the cupcake. I also wasn’t impressed with the presentation of the cupcake, even though they pipe on the icing only after a cupcake is ordered, it didn’t cover the entire top of the cupcake, one of my pet peeves. It also wasn’t very visually pleasing, definitely not the type of cupcake I would as a gift. As I mentioned before, there was only one cupcake to choose from when I was there – I would have preferred to try the Amaretto cupcake as it is at least a unique flavour.

All in all, the only thing the Dessert Lady has going for it is the individual semi reusable container the cupcake came in, and the  location, though with three-four Starbucks in close proximity I’d rather go there for a cupcake than return to the Dessert Lady.

I went to the Wedding Cake Shoppe a week after going to Miss Cora’s Kitchen. One of the masterminds behind this shoppe, placed second during a Food Network Challenge. Though I had been disappointed by Miss Cora’s Kitchen, I went into the Wedding Cake Shoppe with high hopes. I purchased a Caffe Mocha Cupcake and a Spiced Chai Latte, which I feel were the perfect choices for my coffee/cupcake love affair.

Presentation: 5/5
Icing: 5/5
Cake: 5/5
Selection: 5/5
Location: 3/5
Total: 23/25
This cupcake was absolutely amazing. I am obviously a huge caffeine addict, so the combination of coffee, chocolate and cupcakes has me in heaven. The icing on the Caffe Mocha cupcake was mousse-like, making it very light with a hint of coffee taste. The crunchy coffee bean on top was the cherry on top for someone like me. The cake was perfectly moist, combining perfectly with the icing.

Presentation: 5/5
Icing: 4/5
Cake: 5/5
Selection: 5/5
Location: 3/5
Total: 22/25
The Spiced Chai Latte Cupcake was not as good as the Caffe Mocha cupcake, but it was still better than many I’ve had. The icing had a hint of flavour, but was much thicker, making it a heavier icing. As a result there was not as much icing on the cupcake, which I thought worked well well this style of icing. The cake was very similar, nice and moist. While I wasn’t as fond of this cupcake, it is a unique flavour I haven’t seen before, and I feel like it would be good for the person that prefers cupcakes with less icing.

The shop is located near College & Ossington, making it a bit out of the way from my usual College St/Kensington excursions, but on a nice day the walk was pleasant. As they do wedding cake consultation, there are a lot of tables in the shop. The atmosphere is very stimulating as there are lots of pretty cakes to admire in the window. They serve coffee there as well, though I didn’t eat in the shop.

Overall, the Wedding Cake Shoppe offered up a really good cupcake, and I would highly recommend checking it out. So far it they served up the best cupcakes I have found in Toronto.

The third stop on my cupcake quest, was Miss Cora’s Kitchen, “home to Toronto’s best cupcake?” according to their website. Below this quizzical disclaimer is an invitation to come and be the judge. I had high hopes for this place as not only do they have rave reviews online, but they are in Kensington market, one of my favourite areas in Toronto.

Flavour: Double Chocolate
Cake:3/5
Icing:3/5
Flavour:Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing
Cake:3/5
Icing:4/5
Presentation:3/5
Flavour Selection:1/5
Location:5/5
Total Points:15/25 and 16/25

Despite my high hopes for Miss Cora’s Kitchen I was disappointed from the moment I arrived at the shop.  I’ve never been a fan of mini cupcakes, as I figure you might as well go for the full thing, but I wasn’t excited enough about the cupcakes here to pick up a full size.  Instead I sampled two mini cupcakes, a chocolate one and a carrot cake with cream cheese icing with them.  There was really limited selection when I went, with three types of mini cupcakes but only one type of full size cupcake.

The chocolate cupcake was dry, despite being towered with a thick chocolate icing.  The large amount of icing felt like a compensation for the small amount of cake, but there was just too much on it – I REALLY like icing and all, but it was a thick glob that I did not enjoy.  The icing was also poorly distributed; I would have preferred it reached the sides and wasn’t piled as high.

I’m a huge fan of cupcakes with cream cheese icing; it’s usually a safe choice as cream cheese icing is pretty difficult to mess up.  In my experience I find cupcake places with poor buttercream icing often make up for it with their cream cheese icing.  The icing on this cupcake was fine, but it wasn’t phenomenal.  I was not a fan of the carrot cake at all.  I’ve been spoiled as my mom makes an amazing carrot cake, but I felt Miss Cora’s Kitchen just needs a better recipe.  The cake had an unpleasant texture – there was also coconut and raisins in the cake, two things I don’t believe belong in carrot cake, but that’s just my opinion.  As it was a small cupcake I found the extra ingredients took away from the cake, as there was too much texture in a small amount of cake.

Both cupcakes are okay in terms of presentation, but they do look quite amateur.  What Miss Cora’s Kitchen makes up for in lack of a good cupcake is in location.  I love Kensington Market – it’s walking distance from my apartment and there’s lots to do.  However, next time I’m in Kensington I’m passing by Miss Cora’s Kitchen for cupcakes, though someone ordered pizza while I was there and it smelled delicious.  All in all I would not recommend the cupcakes there and question who called them Toronto’s Best Cupcake – I don’t believe they’ve ever tasted a really good cupcake.

I went on my second cupcake hunt last week before heading home for the holidays. The second stop on my adventure was Dufflet on Queen West. Dufflet is not exclusively a cupcake place; they serve up a plethora or decadent looking desserts. I stopped in at Dufflet following a little shopping, and picked up a few goodies which I enjoyed at home.

Flavour: Double Vanilla
Cake: 5/5
Icing: 4/5
Presentation: 4/5
Flavour Variety: 1/5
Location: 4/5
Total Points: 17/25

I have no hesitations saying that Dufflet serves up a delicious cupcake. The vanilla cake was perfection, topped with a mildly sweet vanilla bean icing.  The one thing that I find sets cupcakes apart is their icing.  While Dufflet ranks high on my list for icing, there was one small problem, the cupcake only has a small spread of icing on it.  As someone who thinks a relatively equal ratio of icing to cake is important in a cupcake I found myself disappointed and craving more when I finished the cupcake.  Dufflet’s cupcake is almost too big – their website lists their cupcake as having a 3″ diameter.  Another aspect I find important for cupcakes is that the icing should go to the edge of the cupcake.  As Dufflet’s cupcakes were not the usual muffin-shaped cupcakes with a narrower base, there was empty space from the edge of the cupcake to where the icing began.

Dufflet isn’t a cupcake-specific shop, but this isn’t where my low flavour variety rating comes from.  My problem with Dufflet was that while they very well may have one of Toronto’s best cupcakes, their cupcakes are hidden behind too many other desserts.  In my treat selection, I not only purchased a Double Vanilla Cupcake, but I also purchased a Chocolate Espresso Cheesecake Mini.  It was absolutely orgasmic, causing me to recommend Dufflet for its specialty desserts over cupcakes – as a cupcake lover, that is taboo.  Additionally, Dufflet does not label what all of their desserts are, something that always makes the choosing process difficult as while everything looks so amazing, I would rather choose based on flavours and tastes I like rather than appearance.

The location of Dufflet is fairly close to my favourite shops on Queen West, making it a good spot to get a sugar boost during a day of walking and shopping.  However, in terms of going for cupcakes, it is a little out of the way for a limited selection of flavours.

My favourite place to go in Calgary when I am home, is Crave Cupcakes.  These are not only the most amazing cupcakes, but they also hold sentimental value for me.  Many a special occasion in my life has been enjoyed over a Crave cupcake – no event is too minor for a cupcake.

When I moved away from Calgary, I knew one of the things I’d miss most was Crave.  Sad, but true, one of the things I love most about my hometown is our cupcakes.  Most times I am home, I am greeted with a pack of Crave cupcakes purchased before my arrival by my mom.

I am constantly on the search for a cupcake better than or even comparable to Crave.  So far, despite the many cupcake places I’ve tried, there has yet to be one that comes close to being as good.  Despite living in Toronto for over a year, I have yet to really venture to the cupcake shops.  Most of them are out of my way, but I have decided that a quest for a comparable cupcake to Crave is necessary, especially since I plan to stay here in the summer.  My plan is, using Crave as my standard, to rate cupcake shops based on five categories: Cake, icing, presentation, flavour selection and store location.

While the first four categories are relatively straight forward, the last requires a small explanation.  One of the best things about Crave is that the first two locations were opened in my favourite areas of Calgary, Kensington and 17th Avenue.  As much as I love cupcakes, if the only thing I can do near the cupcake shop is eat cupcakes, I am unlikely to go out of my way.

So, the quest for the best cupcake in Toronto is now underway.